doublefeh, although suitably modified since if he did it, why shouldn't I?I want you, dear reader, whoever you are, to ask me exactly three questions about everything. I will probably even provide you with a truthful answer. Then copy and paste this to your own journal.
The difficulty of asking a finite number of questions about everything is left as an exercise for the reader. Which is a fancy way of saying, "I dunno if it can be done, either, so I'll let somebody else worry about it."
April 15 2004, 00:51:54 UTC 11 years ago
April 15 2004, 01:04:50 UTC 11 years ago
April 15 2004, 00:52:37 UTC 11 years ago
1) Does science explain everything?
2) Does religion explain everything?
3) If "no" to 1 and/or 2, what does explain everything?
April 15 2004, 01:04:35 UTC 11 years ago
2) No. It only (meaningfully) discusses phenomena about which falsifiable predictions can't be made.
3) Nothing, meaningfully. Science and religion could each explain subsets of their respective domains, but there's too much of "everything" to be explicable. (By which I mean, any explanation would be sufficiently complicated as to be incomprehensible, and therefore not much of an explanation - both in the general metaphorical sense, and the rather specific Godel's First Theorem sense. Even assuming a simple underlying principle, the complexity inherent in understanding the composite everything is so great that simple knowledge of the principle is still only a very tiny part of the problem as a whole, in the same way that atomic physics doesn't tell you much of value about the turbulent flow of water.)
But you can learn interesting things about the subsets, at least. :)
April 15 2004, 01:37:30 UTC 11 years ago
April 17 2004, 00:21:29 UTC 11 years ago
April 18 2004, 17:16:45 UTC 11 years ago
My three (well, 2.5)
April 15 2004, 05:29:44 UTC 11 years ago
2) Why is there hate?
3) Why Carrot Top?
Re: My three (well, 2.5)
April 17 2004, 00:22:39 UTC 11 years ago
The division points between the solutions are left as an exercise for the reader.
errrr...um...
April 15 2004, 07:31:51 UTC 11 years ago
Why do think emotional pain happens?
What is your theory of why this world exsists?
Re: errrr...um...
April 17 2004, 00:28:47 UTC 11 years ago
Which I suppose answers the first one as well. :)
April 15 2004, 08:20:54 UTC 11 years ago
Why should I ask you three questions? And what're you gonna do if I don't ask questions, hmm? What's the point of all these meme-things, anyway?
April 16 2004, 23:53:59 UTC 11 years ago
April 15 2004, 09:33:03 UTC 11 years ago
2) What is your favourite colour?
3) What is the wing speed of an unladen European swallow?
April 16 2004, 23:57:41 UTC 11 years ago
2. Babylon... no... aaargh!
3.
April 15 2004, 09:33:12 UTC 11 years ago
If 42 is the answer, what is the question?
Do you really want to ask me three questions?
April 16 2004, 23:58:20 UTC 11 years ago
2. Why?
3. Sure.
April 15 2004, 16:14:34 UTC 11 years ago
2. Why does the west wind blow?
3. Would you give me your name?
April 17 2004, 00:03:44 UTC 11 years ago
2. To keep a steady but gentle flow of dreams moving from the slumbering world to the waking, of course.
3. My name is kept in a well-hidden place, inscribed on a stone stele in an ancient alphabet, hidden in a duck's egg, hidden in a box, hidden in a sun, hidden absolutely nowhere, since I have the sense not to write down my name.
April 15 2004, 19:31:51 UTC 11 years ago
How?
Why?
April 17 2004, 00:04:54 UTC 11 years ago
Thus?
Otherwise...?
I never metaquestion I...
April 16 2004, 01:18:34 UTC 11 years ago
2. If there were some way of asking about everything in a finite number of question, what would your answers to that set of questions be?
3. Are you happy?
Re: I never metaquestion I...
April 17 2004, 00:16:49 UTC 11 years ago
(Hey, I didn't say I knew what the answers actually were)
2. Mu.
3. Funny, I've been asked this before. I have my health; I have my friends; I have work which is meaningful and important; I have my studies; I have enough to eat and a roof over my head. [Knock on wood]
Re: I never metaquestion I...
April 18 2004, 21:06:05 UTC 11 years ago
And I admit I'm still curious about answer #3! I've many times thought along the lines of, "I have foo, I have bar, I have baz... but they still don't necessarily mean I'm happy! Why?" (A partial resolution was from realizing that I had framed the question/answer to myself in terms of what I was "supposed" to want.)
Re: I never metaquestion I...
April 19 2004, 01:15:14 UTC 11 years ago
I guess that what's important in answering a question like that is to pare down the list of things to check for to the things which are really important and not quite as easily affected by outside circumstance.
The "knock on wood" is just old habit. :)
So let me ask a counter-question: when you have foo, bar and baz and are unhappy, what are foo, bar and baz, and what did you omit from that list?